Grand Prairie, TX – The Midlothian Panthers pulled off one of their most testing wins of the season Friday night as they took down the Highland Park Fighting Scots 28-27 in overtime during the area round of the Texas high school football playoffs. After a scoreless first half, both offenses came to life in the second as the Panthers overcame a late Highland Park comeback before holding on for a one-point victory in overtime.
The Rundown
The game got off to a slow start as Highland Park received the opening kickoff and began moving the ball down the field. Quarterback Buck Randall helped lead the Scots on a 15-play, 70-yard drive that took nearly six minutes off the clock. However, the Panthers’ defense would hold strong in the red zone forcing the Scots to attempt a a 27-yard field goal from Shep Pryor that went wide right to leave the game scoreless midway into the first. Midlothian then struggled to find success offensively in their first drive going three and out to begin the exchange of punts between the two teams to close out the opening quarter.
The defensive battle continued throughout the second as neither side was able to break through the 50-yard line until Highland Park got another opportunity late in the half after recovering a Midlothian fumble in enemy territory. Randall quickly moved the Scots deep into Panther’s territory, but the Midlothian defense came up with another big play as Deandre Smith made a diving interception with under 30 seconds remaining in the half. The Panthers then took a knee to end the half as the two sides entered the locker room tied at zero.
Coming out of halftime, Midlothian’s adjustments made an immediate impact as quarterback Justice Roberts led the Panthers on an 11-play, 56-yard drive. Roberts connected with Brendyn Jackson for a 15-yard gain before finding Rodney Jones for a 30-yard touchdown pass to give Midlothian a 7-0 lead early in the second half. However, Highland Park made some adjustments of their own responding with a lengthy drive of its own as Randall began to find success through the air. After connecting with Luke Cecil for a 24-yard gain to move the ball inside the Midlothian 5-yard line, James Flowers punched the ball in from 4 yards out to put the Fighting Scots on the board. However, the kicking troubles continued as Pryor missed the extra point allowing the Panthers to keep a 7-6 lead late in the third quarter.
Midlothian’s next drive would bleed into the fourth quarter as they began to pick up momentum marching down the field and capping off a 13-play drive with a 10-yard touchdown run from Dexter Wright to extend the lead to 14-6 early in the final quarter. Highland Park continued to battle as Randall helped lead the Fighting Scots on a 70-yard touchdown drive. Randall would connect with Caiden Reeves for a 26-yard gain before finding Liam Thomas for a 21-yard touchdown pass on fourth down to keep the drive alive. Thomas would then connect with Evan Snelleman on the two-point conversion to even the game at 14 with just under six minutes remaining. The Panthers responded by turning to their ground game with Roberts breaking free for a 30-yard run to move Midlothian deep into Highland Park territory. Midlothian would then pull out a trick play as Jackson connected with Jones for a 26-yard gain following the double pass to set the Panthers up at the 3-yard line. Wright would finish off the drive with a 1-yard touchdown run to give Midlothian a 21-14 advantage with just under three minutes remaining.
Highland Park answered once more as Randall led the Scots down the field with a series of completions to Thomas, Reeves, and Snelleman. Before Reeves punched the ball in from 8 yards out to tie the game at 21 with just 36 seconds remaining. Midlothian would get one final opportunity to win the game in regulation and rather than taking the knee and playing for overtime Roberts delivered a bomb to Jones for a 34-yard gain moving the Panthers into field goal range. Carter Whitley took the field to attempt the 37-yard field goal attempt with the wind in his favor and the stadium waiting to erupt as he took the three steps to the ball the crowd went silent as the ball went end over end towards the goal post missing just left when it arrived and with the clock showing double zeros the game was headed to overtime tied at 21.
The Panthers would take the first possession of the overtime period and score on that drive on a third down run from Roberts for a 19-yard touchdown, Whitley then connected on the extra point to give Midlothian a 28-21 lead.
Highland Park was ready to respond with a touchdown of their own as Randall connected with Snelleman for an 11-yard gain to move the ball to the Midlothian 1-yard line before Reeves put the ball in from a yard out to bring the Fighting Scots within one at 28-27. However, the kicking trouble continued for Highland Park and this time it would end their season as the extra-point was no good and the Scots fell to the Panthes 28-27.
Midlothian finished the night with 462 yards of total offense, including 280 through the air and 182 on the ground. Highland Park totaled 404 yards, but the Panthers’ defense came up with two interceptions to help secure the victory.
Kee-On Players of the Game: Justice Roberts and Brendyn Jackson
Roberts led the Panthers offensively as he completed 15-of-21 passes for 254 yards and a touchdown while adding 62 rushing yards and another score. His biggest play came in overtime as he broke free for a 19-yard touchdown run to give Midlothian the lead for good.
Jackson was another major factor in the Panthers’ victory as he finished with nine receptions for 145 yards. He also completed a 26-yard pass to Rodney Jones on a trick play late in the fourth quarter, helping set up the touchdown that briefly gave Midlothian a seven-point advantage.
What’s Next
Midlothian will advance to the regional semifinal round of the 5A TXHS playoffs after securing a thrilling overtime victory over Highland Park. The Panthers will take on the undefeated Frisco Lonestar Rangers this week with a date not yet announced. The Rangers come off of a 56-20 victory over the Lancaster Tigers district mate of Midlothian.
Highland Park’s season comes to an end following the one-point upset. They finished the year 8-4 winning the region II district 6-5A title going 6-0 in district play.
