Lex Luger
Luger was a multiple time United States and World Champion and had the perhaps the best body in WCW history. He was always a tweener when it came to the fans however, as a face and a heel he came across lukewarm.
Despite that, the numbers don’t lie and he had one of the greatest careers of all time. It would be sad if the WWE is holding it against him as the first big name to jump ship during the Monday Night Wars.