2 Brian Sipe
While fans may cry over his placement over Kosar, the stats don’t lie. He was the 1980 NFL MVP. Let that sink in for a second, MVP! How many other Browns quarterbacks can say that? Sipe came to Cleveland in 1973 and stayed for an amazing 9 seasons with the team. If not for the USFL, who knows how many more years his NFL career would have lasted.
As a Cleveland Brown, he threw for 23,713 yards, more than any Cleveland Browns quarterback in history. He will be remembered for Red Right 88, but honestly, how much of that is his fault? Sipe was great, and there is no taking it from him.
It has to be Otto Graham.