He meets with Susie but she is unwilling to forgive him for how poorly he spoke to her. She tells him she still needs plenty of time to forgive and simply isn’t willing to commit to anything right now. Maybe, by the time of the finale, but not now.
He then believes this gives him the clarity he has been looking for and perhaps even the closure with Susie. Thus, he decides Rachel is the one, but not before he puts his foot in his mouth one more time and let’s them both know, again, that he went and saw Susie.
First, he breaks it off with Gabby by telling her he met with Susie and is also picking Rachel. This leads to an epic “tell off” moment we have all been craving.
Then, instead of just proposing to Rachel and ending things happy, he cannot resist telling her about the Susie meeting which causes yet another spiral out of control from Rachel who has simply been through enough already. She is now done.
This brings everything back to the stage as he is sitting there with Jesse Palmer and waiting to see if Susie shows up in the end after all? With all that being said, does Susie forgive him and they get together after all of that? We give our prediction on page 3.