November 16, 2026

Despite the Loss the Strongsville Lady Mustangs Walk Away Winners in Character

By Nick Vasko

The Lady Mustangs of Strongsville lost 2-1 in Columbus in the DI State Championship game on Saturday afternoon.  This is not the story I wanted to tell but it is the one I have to write. It isn’t your typical recap with scoring leaders and saves made.  This is about a team who relentlessly pursued greatness but came up short; but only on the scoreboard.  The lessons learned through this season will last forever and these ladies are destined for incredible things inside and outside of soccer for the rest of their lives.

The Saints of Cincinnati Seton were never going to be an easy task to overcome.  They never lost the entire year.  As of this writing, (November 16th, 2026) they are ranked #4 nationally.  They went to the 2025 state championship game as well and felt the same heartbreak that Strongsville did just 2 short days ago.  These are a group of extremely talented young women, and hats off to them.  They Saints earned that championship and they deserved it on Saturday.  Strongsville knew that.  The Mustangs were aware this wasn’t going to be a walk in the park.

Seton scored in the 3rd minute of the game and I felt a wave of anxiety come over the entire Strongsville fan base, and frankly I saw it on the players faces.  As I stood on the sidelines, I’ll admit that I thought to myself “I hope this doesn’t get out of control”.  It’s important to know at this point that I also shoot photography.

 

About 30 seconds passed as Seton’s celebration of their early goal was ending, and at that moment I had a decision to make; should I go down to the other side where I’ll likely get better photos of the girls since Seton was dominating the ball, or should I stay put; right next to the Cincinnati Seton goalie.  I remember as Strongsville was getting ready to kickoff, I looked down the field and didn’t see the anxiety on the Mustangs faces anymore.

 

I looked down and to the left and saw a calm coaching staff and reserve players mimicking that behavior.  It was that moment when I realized the girls in black were going to be fine.  They weren’t going to let it get out of hand, so I stayed where I was.  I believed in this team.  Strongsville held Seton scoreless for the rest of the half.

 

They did more of the same in the second half until the 77th minute of the game.  I was still standing behind the goal Seton was defending starting to feel terrible for Strongsville because was less than 3 minutes remaining, it looked and felt like it was over; but then Ava Anderson, a freshman, did what no one in that stadium expected.

 

She made a run with the ball, dribbled around and beat a senior captain from Seton, and took a shot from just outside of the box.  For a moment, time slowed down and everything got quiet.  I was looking through the viewfinder of my camera when she kicked the ball.  My photographer instincts tell me to keep taking photos but my newfound love for this team took over my brain and I looked away.  I turned my head just in time to see the ball float overtop of the diving the goalie and watched it push against the back of the net.  I didn’t feel like someone from the media anymore covering the event.

I felt like the luckiest person in that stadium to be able to watch greatness, against all odds, from just a few feet away.  The stadium erupted as the volume came rushing back into my ears.  I quickly remembered why I was there and picked my camera back up to get as many photos of that celebration as I could, and it was epic.  Strongsville pulled off what no one thought they could.  They were back in this game with 2 minutes left to play.  Overtime was upon us the rules state that there are 2, 15 minute sudden death periods.

 

Surely with the momentum shifted, there was a real chance the Mustangs could get the victory, or at the very least they were giving themselves a fighting chance.  If you were there, you already know how this story ends.  After a couple back and forth volleys for control of the ball, Cincinnati Seton got an opportunity and Lou Guidugli seized it.  The ball came her way and she took a couple dribbles, looked up, and had an open shot.  In the 80th and final minute of regulation, the Cincinnati Seton Saints reclaimed their destiny and scored.  The final was 2-1 in one of the most gut-wrenching losses in any sport that I’ve ever witnessed.

It’s impossible not to feel for these girls if you know them.  They’ve been playing together for most of their lives, they play exceptional defense, have incredibly strong offense, they are well coached, and they have a lot of fun on and off the pitch.

This was a game that is a not-so-gentle reminder of why we love sports, and why sports are important.  There are so many lessons taught between the sidelines that will get you ready and prepared for the rest of your lives.  Perhaps the most prominent in these girls’ minds right now is that life isn’t always fair.  You deserved to win.

 

You earned your way to that game by being great, but sometimes life doesn’t go the way it’s supposed to.  Unfortunately the world isn’t the plot of a Disney movie and we don’t always win even when we deserve it, but you always keep going and you continue moving forward.  The only time you truly fail is if you quit, which the Strongsville Lady Mustangs never did.

Over the coming days you’ll be able to process the loss and start to reflect positively on your experience.  Going to a state championship isn’t something that comes easy and believe it or not, it isn’t that common.  I promise there will be a day when you wake up and you’re thankful for these experiences if you’re not already.

To the seniors: Hadley Gierosky, Ava Therrien, Izzy Giampetro, Savanna Spisak, Anna Placeway, Marlena Betchker, Mila Stepanovich, & Anna Wheaton:  I just want to thank you for letting me tag along over the past month of your final high school season.  You gave me so much to cheer for and brought back a lot of memories for me that I haven’t thought about in a long time.  It has been an honor to watch all of you play throughout the tournament.

 

My only regret was finding your team so late in the season.  Anna W., you have an infectious smile and even though you weren’t able to play since I’ve been covering this team, it’s evident that you bring so much positivity to this group.  Mila and Marlena, you were a joy to watch.  Anna P, you have been fearless.  I’ve seen you go after the ball gracefully but without hesitation so much.  It’s been awesome to watch.  Savanna, your aggressive style reminds me of myself.  I’ve loved watching you keep your opponent’s away from the goal.  Izzy, you are so much fun to watch but I’ll never forget the regional final where I thought you were going to fight anyone who got in your way.  You always show great loyalty to your teammates.  Ava, I hope you aren’t hard on yourself and I hope you are aware of how skilled you are.  Best goalkeeper I’ve seen in a long time.

 

You singlehandedly kept your team in the state championship by making incredible save after incredible save.  Hadley, you are the best high school soccer player I’ve ever had the pleasure of watching.  You are a great leader and have the skill to back it up.  I’m looking forward to following your journey and seeing what your future holds.  I wish all of you the best in your future endeavors!

To the rest of the team; you are also extremely talented and I think you know that.  The road to Columbus is long but there is no reason you won’t be able to do it again next year!

Congratulations to the Strongsville Lady Mustang soccer team on an incredible season!  Seniors, good luck.  To the rest of you, see you next season!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.