October 9, 2026

The Buckeye Bucks defeat the North Olmsted Eagles 20-17

North Olmsted Ohio – 

FINAL SCORE: The Buckeye Bucks defeat the North Olmsted Eagles 20-17. 

Buckeye received the opening kickoff but fumbled, and North Olmsted quickly took advantage of the turnover with excellent field position. The Eagles faced an early 4th-and-4, but QB Will McPherson connected with TE Billy Suleiman for an 11-yard gain to keep the drive alive and move North Olmsted into the red zone. RB Koen Beasley followed with a pair of strong runs, and an 8-yard reception by WR Cody Jak set the Eagles up at the 1-yard line. Beasley capped the drive with a 1-yard touchdown run, giving North Olmsted a 7-0 lead after capitalizing on the Buckeye fumble. 

Buckeye struggled to generate offense in their first possession. Faced with a 3rd-and-1, the Bucks elected to run the ball but were stopped short of the line of gain and were forced to punt. North Olmsted then took over and quickly moved into Buckeye territory thanks to a 10-yard run by McPherson. A false start penalty backed the Eagles up five yards, but the setback proved insignificant. On the very next play, Koen Beasley broke through the defense for a 53-yard touchdown, extending North Olmsted’s lead to 14-0 with 1:13 remaining in the first quarter. 

Buckeye answered North Olmsted’s second touchdown drive with an impressive scoring drive of their own. A first-down run by Denis Shevchenko and another first-down carry from Liam Phillips moved the Bucks into Eagles territory. QB Shane Metter then connected with WR Tony Kobasuk for a 14-yard gain, pushing Buckeye into the red zone. Phillips continued to move the chains with a pair of productive runs that brought the ball to the 10-yard line. Although a false start penalty backed the Bucks up five yards, the setback proved to be only a minor obstacle. Shevchenko finished the drive with a 3-yard touchdown run, cutting North Olmsted’s lead to 14-7. The Eagles responded with a strong drive of their own.

A 20-yard run by WR Blake Drazen quickly moved North Olmsted into Buckeye territory. An illegal formation penalty pushed the Eagles back five yards on the following play, but they quickly recovered as Koen Beasley broke loose for a 28-yard gain, setting North Olmsted up in the red zone at the Buckeye 18-yard line. Facing a 3rd-and-short situation, Beasley was stopped for no gain while attempting to convert for a first down. North Olmsted turned to kicker Sebastian Mastroianni, who connected on a 29-yard field goal to extend the Eagles’ lead to 17-7 with 1:18 remaining in the first half. 

As halftime approached, Buckeye looked to build momentum and cut further into North Olmsted’s lead. However, an illegal man downfield penalty pushed the Bucks back five yards. Buckeye was still able to respond with a strong first-down run that moved the ball into Eagles territory, giving the offense an opportunity to add points before the break. Facing a 3rd-and-10 from the North Olmsted 38-yard line, Metter took a shot downfield, but the pass was intercepted by DB Michael Flick, ending the Bucks’ scoring threat. The turnover preserved North Olmsted’s advantage and sent the Eagles into halftime with a 17-7 lead over Buckeye. 

North Olmsted was unable to generate much offense on its opening possession of the second half and was forced to punt the ball back to Buckeye. The Bucks took advantage of favorable field position after a strong punt return set them up inside the Eagles’ 25-yard line. Buckeye quickly moved closer to the goal line as Shevchenko broke free for a 16-yard run, advancing the ball to the North Olmsted 3-yard line. After the Eagles’ defense stiffened near the goal line, Buckeye faced a 3rd-and-goal from the 5-yard line. Metter delivered a pass to TE Colton Homchik for a 5-yard touchdown, capping the short drive and cutting North Olmsted’s lead to 17-14 midway through the third quarter. 

North Olmsted’s offensive struggles continued on their next possession. A false start penalty put the Eagles behind the chains and created a 3rd-and-13 situation. Unable to convert for a first down, North Olmsted was forced to punt the ball back to Buckeye. The Bucks appeared poised to take advantage of the opportunity despite an early false start penalty that made it 1st-and-15.  Metter connected with Homchik for a 16-yard gain, and Phillips followed with a 14-yard run to move Buckeye deep into Eagles territory at the North Olmsted 15-yard line.

With momentum building, Buckeye looked ready to tie the game or take the lead. However, a holding penalty, combined with a sideline warning, stalled the drive and backed the Bucks up to the 20-yard line, setting up a difficult 3rd-and-15. Buckeye attempted to pick up the first down through the air, but the pass was dropped, bringing up 4th-and-15. A delay of game penalty then pushed the Bucks back even further, making it 4th-and-20. On the final play of the drive, Metter’s pass into the end zone was knocked away by the Eagles’ defense, resulting in a turnover on downs and preserving North Olmsted’s 17-14 lead taking us to the 4th quarter. 

North Olmsted appeared headed for another quick three-and-out on its next possession after a false start penalty created a 3rd-and-11 situation. However, McPherson came through with a crucial run of more than 20 yards, picking up the first down and moving the Eagles close to midfield. A few plays later, though, North Olmsted squandered the opportunity when Koen Beasley fumbled the ball, and Buckeye recovered at its own 42-yard line. The Bucks looked ready to capitalize on the turnover. An offsides penalty against North Olmsted gave Buckeye a 1st-and-5, and a first-down run by Liam Phillips pushed the ball into Eagles territory. Buckeye’s momentum was slowed by a false start penalty that made it 1st-and-15, but an even bigger setback followed.

A high snap sailed over Metter’s head, and although Buckeye was able to recover the loose ball, the play resulted in a 19-yard loss and set up a daunting 3rd-and-32 situation. Facing long odds, the Bucks kept the ball on the ground and gained 14 yards, but it was nowhere near enough for a first down. Left with a 4th-and-long, Buckeye elected to punt, handing possession back to North Olmsted and allowing the Eagles to maintain their 17-14 advantage with less than 8 minutes left of the 4th quarter. 

North Olmsted’s offense continued to sputter on its next possession and was forced to punt the ball back to Buckeye, giving the Bucks another opportunity to take control of the game. Buckeye answered with one of its most important drives of the night. Facing a 3rd-and-long, Metter connected with Mason Dolata for an 11-yard gain, moving the chains and pushing the Bucks into Eagles territory. Shevchenko followed with an 11-yard run that advanced the ball to the North Olmsted 29-yard line. Buckeye appeared poised to continue the drive on a 3rd-and-3, but a false start penalty backed the offense up and turned it into a more challenging 3rd-and-8 situation.

The Bucks responded with a clutch first-down completion to Colton Homchik, and an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty against North Olmsted moved the ball all the way to the 5-yard line, setting up a 1st-and-goal opportunity. Shevchenko finished off the drive by powering into the end zone from five yards out, giving Buckeye its first lead of the game. The Bucks were unable to convert the extra point, but the touchdown still put Buckeye in front 20-17 late in the game with just over 2 minutes remaining. 

With the game on the line and just over two minutes remaining, North Olmsted had one final opportunity to either tie the score or reclaim the lead. The Eagles moved the ball into a critical 4th-and-3 situation at their own 44-yard line, knowing a conversion was needed to keep their hopes alive. McPherson dropped back to pass, looking to extend the drive, but his throw fell incomplete. The turnover on downs gave Buckeye possession with 1:14 remaining, allowing the Bucks to run out the remaining time and secure the victory.

After trailing 17-7 at halftime, Buckeye rallied with 13 unanswered second-half points, highlighted by two touchdown runs from Denis Shevchenko, to complete the comeback. North Olmsted’s offense was unable to find an answer in the final quarter, and the Eagles’ last-gasp drive ended with the incomplete pass on fourth down. 

North Olmsted was led by QB Will McPherson, who went 10/14 for 56 yards. RB Koen Beasley had 16 carries for 125 yards and 2 touchdowns.  

Buckeye was led by QB Shane Metter, who went 5/12 passing for 49 yards and 1 touchdown. RB’s Liam Phillips had 17 carries for 87 yards; Denis Shevchenko had 11 carries for 78 yards and 2 touchdowns. TE Colton Homchick had 3 receptions for 42 yards and 1 touchdown.  

Player of the Game: Buckeye RB Denis Shevchenko, 11 carries for 78 yards and 2 touchdowns 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.