| Year | OPP | Round |
| 95 | ATL | WS |
| 96 | BAL | DIV |
| 97 | FLO | WS |
| 98 | NYY | ALCS |
| 99 | BOS | DIV |
| 2001 | SEA | DIV |
| 2007 | BOS | ALCS |
| 13 | TB | WC |
| 16 | CHI | WS |
| 17 | NYY | DIV |
| 18 | HOU | DIV |
| 20 | NYY | WC |
| 22 | NYY | DIV |
| 24 | NYY | ALCS |
| 25 | DET | WC |
| Year | OPP | Round |
| 95 | ATL | WS |
| 96 | BAL | DIV |
| 97 | FLO | WS |
| 98 | NYY | ALCS |
| 99 | BOS | DIV |
| 2001 | SEA | DIV |
| 2007 | BOS | ALCS |
| 13 | TB | WC |
| 16 | CHI | WS |
| 17 | NYY | DIV |
| 18 | HOU | DIV |
| 20 | NYY | WC |
| 22 | NYY | DIV |
| 24 | NYY | ALCS |
| 25 | DET | WC |