by 2012
Winner – Sheamus
Who should have won – Chris Jericho
Reason – This was during a time when a returning part time legend was actually cheered and not detested for having a light work schedule and coming and going as they pleased. This would have been the perfect way to bring Jericho back. However, I do see why they gave it to Sheamus considering they then booked him to defeat Daniel Bryan in 18 seconds at WrestleMania 28 to win the World Championship. So, I see it both ways here, honestly.
