2009
Winner – Randy Orton
Who should have won – John Cena
Reason – You see, Cena won it one year too early in our opinion. Considering Cena would eventually go on to defeat Edge and The Big Show for the WWE World Championship at WrestleMania 25, this would have been better sense.
Instead, they have Orton last eliminate HHH, only for Trips to win the title at the Elimination Chamber and then defend it against Orton and defeat him at WrestleMania 25 in a match that no one remembers. I don’t know, but none of this made Orton look strong.