by 2008
Winner – John Cena
Who should have won – HHH
Reason – As cool as it was to see Cena comeback from major injury months ahead of time, it is everything that went down after his win that made it extremely forgettable. He should have come back the next night on Monday Night Raw instead. The win meant nothing as he somehow talked his way into getting the World Title Shot at the February throw away PPV, which made no sense, and lost. Then, on top of that, both he and HHH lost their World Title Challenge to Randy Orton at WrestleMania. Cool memory of seeing Cena come back, but horrible long term storytelling with this one.
